Lately I have been working on some new guitar techniques that are taking me “outside my comfort zone.”
Working on new things can be very unsettling – for all of us. Sometimes feeling like a beginner is fun, but at other times a lot of mental resistance comes up.
(If I tell you what it is you’ll laugh…basic thumb picking. Yep, I can do crazy funk stuff, but some basics still kick my butt..)
Thoughts of quitting started to spring up on their own, without my wanting them to…
- “It’s such a waste of time”
- “It’s just not my thing, I should focus elsewhere”
- “I didn’t grow up with it”
- “I should just focus on what I am good at”
- “There are so many other people who do this well”
- “I’ll never get it!”
Sound familiar?
Why can’t we just keep chipping away at learning new things without any mental resistance?
As it turns out, wanting to quit and run away is a natural reaction to going outside one’s comfort zone.
There’s actually a very good reason that these thoughts come up…
(And at the end of this post I will give you 3 techniques to “defuse” this type of negative thinking so you can chip away at new things, out of your comfort zone and understand what’s happening inside you.)
Your 2 Selves: The Observer & The Thinker
I am currently reading The Happiness Trap: How to Stop Struggling and Start Living: A Guide to ACT
To start, let’s say that we have 2 selves – the observing self and the thinking self.
The observing self watches and it does not judge:
“I played a wrong a note in this spot.” No emotions, just the fact.
The thinking self then chimes in and loves to judge:
“If I keep making mistakes like this wrong note…
I will be a failure,
I might be rejected,
I might not make a living,
Everyone will think I am a fraud,
I’ll spend the rest of my life trying to do this and maybe never get it!”
This “thinking self” will never shut up. The more we try to silence it or ignore it, the worse it gets.
Why does the thinking self make non stop commentary? Here’s why…
Don’t Get Killed
This thinking brain function was necessary for our survival 100,000 years ago. It’s the deep seated “don’t get killed!” survival function a work.
Quite often we feel “fight or flight” responses in situations that are not at all life threatening.
The original use of “thinking mind” was for…
- Is that dark shape a boulder or a bear?
- Is the fruit safe to eat or poisonous?
- Is that person a friend or foe?
An important factor in not getting yourself killed is to get to know your environment.
The better you know the terrain and the local wildlife, then the safer you are, wheras venturing into unknown territory exposes you to all sorts of exotic dangers.
Knowing your terrain = Comfort Zone
Outside your terrain, possible danger = Outside Your Comfort Zone
Here is a quote from The Happiness Trap
Those demons will keep showing up again and again, as soon as you start to take your life in a valued direction.
Thus, as you start to do something new, our mind will start warning us: you might fail, you might make a mistake, you might get rejected. It warns us with negative thoughts, disturbing images, bad memories and a wide range of uncomfortable feelings and sensations.
All too often, we let these warnings stop us form taking life in the direction we really want.
You may choose to pursue a new career, relationship, or engage in a challenging project and what I guarantee you is this: whatever meaningful changes you start to make in your life, the demons will rear their ugly heads and try to discourage you.
He also says it’s a far stretch to just think we’ll turn this off with ‘positive thinking’, and he offers what he calls “defusion” as the first step in “ACT” (Acceptance & Commitment Therapy).
“Defusing” Facts from Thoughts
When a fact a thought are “fused” together we tend take a story and event and stick them together as one.
In a state of fusion we believe out thoughts to be true, important, wise, reality – deserving of our full attention.
Fact: There is heavy traffic as you a driving somewhere important like a wedding.
Thought: “This shouldn’t be happening right now, I need to get there!”
Thought: “Why does this always happen to me?”
Thought: “I should have left earlier!”
This thought and the fact get “fused” and then we feel an emotional impact which is not very pleasant.
In The Happiness Trap
What we are left with is clarity, distance from our thoughts, and less emotional impact.
He claims that feeling better is a “by product” and that the goal is to “defuse” rather than just feel better.
3 Defusion techniques to get you started.
Please take a moment now to play with the techniques, and put these into practice. You’ll giggle when you see how well they work.
1. The “I am having the thought that…” Technique
If you insert this phrase before stating your emotion, it creates a magic distance.
Before: “I am nervous”
After: “I am having the thought that I am nervous”
Before: “I am too old to learn this”
After: “I am having the thought that I am too old to learn this”
By stating “I am having the thought that…” you allow the emotion or feeling to be without trying to suppress, and you take the position of observer.
This phrase gives you a little distance from the unpleasant thought. You realize the thought is just a sound, not reality.
2. The “Funny Voices” Defusion Technique
Say the thought you are having with a funny comedy voice like Homer Simpson, Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck or even Yoda or Darth Vader.
All of a sudden the though of “Oh God! I suck at guitar!” becomes hilarious when any of these voices say it.
3. The “Name Your Story” Defusion Technique
If you start getting stressed about something, like your car needs a sudden repair and you get stressed about the sudden high expense…
You can say “It’s the ‘expensive car repair’ story.”
As you can see, this gives you distance and unhooks the emotion & stress just a little bit.
The facts remain but the feeling lightens up.
Musical & Personal Application
For new skills and practicing guitar, if you are feeling frustrated you can try these techniques. Here are some suggestions.
“I am having the thought that…”
This first thought puts pressure on you:
“I need to practice more!”
This gives you some distance and relief:
“I am having the thought that I need to practice more”
Funny Voices
- Have you made a mistake, hit a wrong note? Say “oops I made a mistake!” in Homer Simpsons voice.
- Are you sweating a technique like thumb picking? Have Darth Vader say “I am having difficulty thumb picking!”
- Are you telling yourself stuff like “I’ll never get this!” Now say it in a Bugs Bunny voice.
And so on. You get the idea. It’s a simple and silly sounding technique, but it works and goes way down into your psyche will help “unhook” you.
Naming the story technique (I already do this on stage)
I have several scenarios which used to make me very nervous & uncomfortable, and now I just say “It’s the _________ story again!”
- The Monitor Sound Sucks Story
- The I Just Botched a Note Story
- The Guitar is Feeding Back Story
- The Soundman is a Jerk Story
Once I acknowledge it as story, it’s back under my control and I can be present to play music instead of “spin” in thought.
I guess once something has happened enough and you know it’s not life or death, you become familiar with the situations.
In Conclusion
Remember, it is often the “new territory” that triggers an unsafe feeling and makes us want to turn back to the comfort zone.
Play with these techniques, and be sure to check out The Happiness Trap: How to Stop Struggling and Start Living: A Guide to ACT
Keep up the good fight and never ever give up!
Latest posts by adamrafferty (see all)
- FGH-0009: How can you overcome nervousness and panic when playing solo fingerstyle guitar onstage? - September 11, 2018
- FGH-0008: Interview with Robin Bullock – Celtic Guitar, Mandolin, Cittern and More… - August 30, 2018
- FGH-0007: Interview with Guitarist Mike Dowling – American Roots, Bottleneck Blues, Ragtime and More… - August 9, 2018
Hi Adam,
another great and valueable advice especially for old men like me š ! Thanks for these initial words. I just was having the thought that I am too old to learn this … See you in Blomberg Oct 24!
Cheers from Lemgo and all the best on the road
Bernd
Bernd, looking forward to 24-10!!!! AR
This is Adam testing the new CAPTCHA plugin, please look for nothing of meaning in my comment š
Adam AGAIN. That last test was in Chrome, this is on Safari, using the same google Recaptcha š
I listened to you played “Imagine” acoustic guitar finger style and I loved it. I want to learn.
Do you have a guitar tab of the song. I would like to give it a try.
Thanks
Sid
Hi Adam,
Thanks for another great article. I started playing guitar because of the anxiety issues that I suffer with. You should have seen me shaking going into my first guitar lesson, with my brand new guitar, totally out of my comfort zone!! I am now 9 months into my guitar journey, and I am less stressed about everything. Reading Julia Cameron’s book ‘the Artist’s Way’, really started me on the path dealing with these same issues. Thanks for sharing that professionals get these feelings too! Sometimes, it’s easy to forget!
Smart!
Hi Adam very nice and helpful thoughts! Thank you for his!
I’m having the thought I’m having a one sided bromance with Adam. LOL
Thanks for the article. Very helpful, yes.
It’s pretty obvious that you are a spiritual seeker. I recognize my kind. Some part of you is seeking , even when you’re playing concerts, in the dark, some part of you is always seeking. You know very well, at least intellectually, that it’s all just a mental game, that in the end, it’s all illusory. The autonomous mental activity of the brain, creates the illusion that there’s someone behind the scenes.
The wave takes itself to be different from the ocean. The wave feels little, isolated; it’s afraid to die.
When you introduce the notion of the “observer and the “thinker”. Are you not creating a “third entity” that is now considering the doings of the observer and the thinker? I feel that this approach only makes the problem more complex. Like a hall of mirrors, is this not a game of infinite reflections.?
Have you ever considered that the idea of a self could be false? Because if the self is false, anything and everything related to the false self has to necessarily be false as well.
I feel that when the false self believes to see something very clearly, in its excitement , which is really confusion, wants to transmit this new revelation to others. (people usually write books).
But whatever conclusion the false self arrives at, however brilliant, has to be false. It’s like trying to solve the malfunction of an imaginary engine, it’s impossible.
There are no solutions to the problems of an imaginary self.
Sometimes guitar playing /practicing/performing is a problem and sometimes it isn’t. So which is it? Is it a problem or not? This should give you a clue that “the player ” is a false assumption. The guitar itself, however, always is. The guitar is real and does not participate in our human fiction. So what’s the reality of playing guitar?
Could the guitar be played without oxygen, gravity, water, etc? Obviously not. Which means you need a solar system to supply you with these things. Could the guitar be played if the community of other humans weren’t growing your food, providing you with electricity, etc.? Seeing this very clearly destroys the idea of individual action.
So what are the solutions for guitar frustrations/fears? When frustrations/fears are present, it’s already too late. The frustration is energy that once released cannot go back to its original source. It usually dissipates after a while. Frustration returns because the false self has created an imaginary ideal that it cannot accomplish or that it’s fearful it might not be able to accomplish. If there were no “ideals” there would be no frustrations. (I feel that the nobility we place in ideals and goals is so ingrained in us that it prevents access to spirit)
When I am in “self” I am susceptible to all of the things of the self: frustration, anger, excitement, guilt, elation, envy, jealousy, etc. When I simply am; the only actor is the whole universe. Most of us function in this way. In self-universe, in self-universe. ( I imagine that very accomplished human beings spend most of their time in universe).
It’s easy to recognize when you’re simply the universe. It’s when the room you’re in, or the place you’re in comes alive. You notice the light caught in a strand of spider web. You find your breath in your body and notice how your belly rises and falls. When you attack a new piece of music and spend hours simply doing it, without your mind coming in with comments about the experience. When you’re very quiet and peaceful.
Caution for new spiritual seekers: the false self has its role in life. When the false self says : “you’d better pay your taxes by April 15th or you’ll have to pay penalties” or “the treads in your tires are flat, that’s dangerous.” Please listen to this.
But when the false self says: “You’re never going to play guitar like Adam”, “You’re a loser”. “You have no talent”; this is the human fiction. But this verbal abuse only works if I believe that I am a separate, independent entity that owns his thinking and feeling, and seeing, etc.
If I see that all the mental activity relating to an imaginary self is false, then it has no effect on me.
Seeing the falseness of the mental activity turns it into a monotonous sound, like the constant hissing of a nearby freeway; it’s always there but it does not affect you.
This is my reaction to your post (which I always enjoy, by the way).
Live long and prosper.
Thanks a gain. This is applicable to everything, meaning LIFE.
What I find out in life, in fact, ” comfort zone”is not comforting at all. It prevents you from any type of pleasure you would get in achieving something meaningful. How small it may be.
“Just do it “is a good summary for this article in my opinion.
Thanks a bunch!!!!